There are so many farming games out there now that I genuinely don’t know how anyone is supposed to keep track of all of them anymore. Stardew Valley is still the one most fans of the genre probably talk about, and every year seems to bring another farming game that manages to break through and find a decent-sized audience of its own. Unfortunately, that also means plenty of really good ones come and go without getting anywhere near the amount of attention they probably deserved. A new farming sim can look great and review incredibly well, but if it launches at the wrong time or doesn’t immediately catch on, it’s pretty easy for everyone to move on without ever realizing what they missed.
That’s especially unfortunate because player counts don’t always tell the same story as player reception. Some farming games have attracted remarkably small audiences on Steam, while the people who actually found them have been almost universally positive about what they played. When a game can barely get a few hundred people playing at the same time but still walk away with a 94% or 95% positive rating, I have a hard time believing quality was the problem. These five farming games are some of the clearest examples of great games that almost nobody showed up to play.
For added context, “near-perfect” refers to games with exceptionally strong Steam user scores, while “nobody played” is based on unusually low Steam player counts relative to that reception.
Before The Green Moon
Somehow, This 94%-Positive Farming Game Peaked at Eight Players
94% positive from 138 Steam reviews.
8-player peak. Sci-fi farming beneath a space elevator.
I’m starting with Before The Green Moon because I still can’t quite get over that number. According to SteamDB, this farming game has never had more than eight people playing it on Steam at the same time. Eight. That’s not the number playing it right now or even its average during a particularly slow month. That’s the highest concurrent player count it has ever reached. Meanwhile, 94% of its 138 Steam reviews are positive, which makes this one of the strangest gaps between player reception and player count I’ve seen in quite some time.
Put the consoles in the correct order.
Easy (5)
Medium (7)
Hard (10)
Start
The game itself is also far more interesting than its tiny audience would suggest. Before The Green Moon is a science-fiction farming sim set in a small community beneath a space elevator, and the player’s eventual goal is to leave that community behind for the moon. Until then, life is considerably more grounded. You’re growing crops and getting to know the people around you while the seasons slowly move you closer to your departure. There’s a quietness to the whole premise that immediately distinguishes it from the usual “inherit a farm and save the town” setup, and Steam’s 94% positive score suggests the handful of people who actually gave it a chance found plenty to like. It’s just a shame there were apparently never more than eight of them in the same room at once.
Shinehill
Almost Everyone Who Found This Farming RPG Seems to Love It
95% positive from 260 Steam reviews.
58-player peak. An alien spy tries to blend into island life.
Shinehill is a much newer game than most of the others here, so there’s obviously still time for it to find a bigger audience. Still, it launched in March 2026 and has so far reached an all-time Steam peak of only 58 concurrent players, according to SteamDB. That’s especially surprising when its actual reception has been this strong. Of the 260 reviews currently on Steam, 95% are positive. In other words, the problem certainly doesn’t appear to be that people played Shinehill and hated it. There just haven’t been very many people playing it in the first place.
The premise is also considerably weirder than its charming, Stardew Valley-like art style might initially let on. Players are actually a spy on an unfamiliar planet who gets mistaken for a new resident of Shinehill Island. Rather than correcting anyone, they move into a house and start trying to blend in. Farming naturally becomes part of that new life, but there’s also this underlying question of why the player was sent there to begin with and what exactly is happening on the island. It’s a fun way to give the usual cozy farming setup a little more going on underneath it, and the fact that Shinehill has maintained a 95% positive rating makes its 58-player peak look even more bizarre.
Related
Cozy Games Keep Leaving the Farm Behind, and Steam’s Latest Overwhelmingly Positive Hit Shows Why
Cozy games have spent years chasing Stardew Valley, but one of Steam’s latest hits shows the genre may finally be ready to move on.
Research Story
Farming Is Only Half the Job Here
94% positive from 307 Steam reviews.
139-player peak. Farming revolves around field research.
Research Story is probably the easiest recommendation here for someone who wants a farming game that still feels comfortably within the genre while doing something a little different with it. Players arrive in Shimmerbrook as a researcher working with the Violet Archive, which has been established to document the unusual plants and creatures appearing around the region. That means the farm isn’t really the end goal on its own. It’s part of the player’s research, since wild plants can eventually be grown as crops and creatures can be studied before they’re tamed.
Apparently, the people who discovered it were very happy with that idea. Research Story currently has 94% positive reviews on Steam, but SteamDB shows an all-time concurrent peak of just 139 players. That peak came around its full release in July 2025, so it isn’t like we’re looking at an Early Access game that simply hasn’t had its real launch yet either. It did, and people liked it. But almost nobody showed up. There’s something especially frustrating about seeing numbers like that when the farming genre is already full of players looking for their next Stardew Valley-style obsession, because Research Story is sitting right there with a 94% score and barely managed to get 139 people through the door at once.
Related
5 Best Farming Sims Like Stardew Valley
If you’re looking for the next great farming sim, these titles will scratch that Stardew Valley itch.
Snacko
Rebuilding an Island as a Cat Apparently Wasn’t Enough to Get People In
95% positive from 887 Steam reviews.
317-player peak. Farming helps rebuild an abandoned island.
Snacko has actually managed to collect far more Steam reviews than most of the games here, which makes its player-count situation a little strange in a different way. Its 887 reviews are 95% positive, enough for Steam to label its overall reception Overwhelmingly Positive. However, SteamDB shows that its all-time concurrent peak stopped at only 317 players. That’s certainly more than eight, but for a farming game this well-liked, it’s still remarkably small.
Its setup is pretty interesting too. You and your childhood friend leave home because the cost of living has gotten out of hand, which might be one of the more painfully relatable reasons anyone has ever ended up on a farming-game adventure. From there, the two head to the abandoned Snacko Island and start rebuilding it into somewhere people actually want to live again. The player has a direct hand in bringing the town back, so there’s a bit more to the experience than simply tending a farm until the money starts rolling in. Also, everyone is a cat, which feels like something that should have sold the game by itself. Somehow, though, Snacko never got anywhere close to the audience its 95% Steam score suggests it could have.
Related
8 Indie Games About Being A Cat
Being a cat isn’t always what it’s cracked up to be…
Wylde Flowers
This One Came Closest to Breaking Through, but Still Never Really Did
96% positive from 1,699 English Steam reviews.
653-player peak. Farming meets a fully voiced witch story.
Wylde Flowers is easily the biggest game on this list, so calling it something “nobody played” takes a little more explaining. It was released outside Steam as well, and it has obviously built more of a following than something like Before The Green Moon. Still, its Steam numbers are surprisingly modest when compared with how overwhelmingly positive its reception has been. 96% of its 1,699 English-language Steam reviews are positive, while its all-time concurrent Steam peak is only 653 players. It is literally the most-played game here, and even it never cracked 700.
In Wylde Flowers, players take on the role of Tara, who moves to the rural island of Fairhaven to help her grandmother with the family farm. It starts from a pretty recognizable farming-game setup, but Tara is also a witch, and her magical life gradually becomes just as important as what she’s doing on the farm. The story is fully voiced in English too, which gives Wylde Flowers a more narrative-heavy feel than a lot of games in the genre. Clearly, something about it worked, because getting 96% of nearly 1,700 English Steam reviews to come back positive is no small accomplishment. The surprising part is that, at least on Steam, there were never more than 653 people playing it at once.
