Halloween 3 Made the Right Choice by Getting Rid of Michael Myers

In 1978, John Carpenter introduced audiences to Michael Myers in the original Halloween. Michael quickly became one of the most iconic villains in the horror genre, thanks to his horrifying mask and complete lack of conscience. Michael survived several gunshots and a stumble off a roof, returning to kill again in 1981’s Halloween 2. The sequel’s ending left Michael’s fate much less ambiguous, as the villain seemingly died in a fiery explosion alongside doctor Samuel Loomis. With the story seemingly concluded, 1982’s Halloween 3: Season of the Witch shifted focus as the only film in the franchise to leave Michael Myers behind.

Michael Myers’ absence proved to be hugely controversial. While Halloween 3 made a profit for Universal, it failed to reach the commercial and critical heights of its predecessors. Six years after Season of the Witch, the slasher villain was brought back with the appropriately titled Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers. From then on, Michael remained the primary focus of the franchise, plaguing an ever-changing cast of protagonists across multiple sequels, remakes, and reboots. Despite Season of the Witch’s initial reception and the absence of its central villain, fans have reevaluated the movie, which is now considered one of the best in the series.

Related

Why Halloween 3 Is One of the Best Movies in the Halloween Franchise

In the absence of Michael Myers, Halloween 3 needed a new storyline and set of characters. The 1982 horror movie follows Daniel Challis (Tom Atkins), a doctor who finds himself pursuing a mystery involving Ellie Grimbridge (Stacey Nelkin). Daniel could not have been more different from Samuel Loomis: as a hard-drinking, womanizing divorcee, he makes for an unlikely hero. However, when Ellie’s father is brutally murdered at the hospital, the doctor agrees to help her investigate the mysterious Silver Shamrock Novelties. That investigation brings them into direct conflict with Conal Cochran, played by Dan O’Herlihy. Cochran is no Myers, but his plans for Halloween night are no less sinister.

Michael Myers prefers to kill his victims with a blade, but Cochran aims to wipe out children around the world using a mix of technology and witchcraft. Silver Shamrock’s signature Halloween masks are designed to kill the wearer during a special television broadcast, unleashing insects and snakes that also kill anyone else nearby. The company advertised this to children as a “big giveaway,” encouraging everyone to hurry home from trick-or-treating to watch. Ellie’s father discovered Cochran’s plans for a mass sacrifice, and the Silver Shamrock owner sent one of his robotic minions to silence him ahead of time. Halloween 3 ends on an ambiguous note, as Daniel pleads to get the broadcast pulled from the airwaves.

Related

Part of the appeal of Halloween 3 is that it crafts a unique and compelling story that works as a standalone film. Its bleak tone, daring narrative, and unforgettable iconography make the franchise’s third installment a great option during the spooky season. Atkins does an excellent job of bringing Daniel to life as a flawed hero who’s easy to root for, and there are also plenty of moments that have ingrained themselves in popular culture in the decades since the film’s release. The Silver Shamrock designs might not be as iconic as the converted William Shatner mask used in the original Halloween, but it’s totally plausible that their simplicity would appeal to kids in the ’80s. Of course, Silver Shamrock’s hypnotic, eerie earworm of a commercial jingle is also timeless.

Halloween 3 Made Michael’s Return All the Sweeter

Had Halloween 3 been named anything else, it probably wouldn’t have been maligned for so many years. The film had all the makings of a cult classic from the ’80s. It has an excellent synth soundtrack (composed by Carpenter), as well as imaginative and creepy deaths. Despite being largely disconnected from everything that came before, the movie does have some light connective tissue with the rest of the series. In the world of Halloween 3, the original Halloween exists as a successful movie. In fact, Conal Cochran’s broadcast takes place after an airing of the original Michael Myers movie on TV. Nancy Loomis also appears, playing a different role than she did in the two Halloween films that preceded it; this time, she appears as Linda Challis. The recent Halloween trilogy from Blumhouse even includes references to Season of the Witch, with characters seen wearing Silver Shamrock’s trademark masks.

Halloween 3 might seem like a misstep, but it likely helped drive greater interest in Michael Myers. The ’80s were an era of excess for horror, and characters like Jason Voorhees and Freddy Krueger appeared in a whole collection of sequels throughout that decade. Many of those follow-ups were subpar and seen as inferior to the originals. Giving audiences an extended break from the franchise’s signature killer likely helped drive more interest in his return; Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers was a commercial hit, and it remains a fan favorite.

If Halloween 3: Season of the Witch had become an instant success, the franchise would’ve taken on an anthology format, with different characters and storylines appearing in each subsequent movie. That clearly didn’t pan out, but it did result in one of the best entries in the Halloween series. Season of the Witch is weird and scary in a very different way from the other Michael Myers films, but its uniqueness helps it stand out decades after its release. Michael Myers is the undisputed ruler of the Halloween season, but for a brief window, it was Conal Cochran and Silver Shamrock that reigned supreme.