The Biggest Problem With Robert Downey Jr.’s Doctor Doom May Already Be Gone

When Robert Downey Jr. was announced as the MCU’s Doctor Doom in Avengers: Doomsday, Marvel created a huge problem for itself. Downey had become synonymous with Tony Stark, and his return only a few years after Avengers: Endgame immediately raised an obvious question: was the MCU really bringing back one of its most iconic actors to play an entirely different character, or would Victor Von Doom just feel like Iron Man in a different mask?

The first Avengers: Endgame teaser has been released, and it has immediately silenced those concerns. The footage has sparked backlash over other elements of the highly-anticipated MCU team-up, from its visual style to its crossover premise. But the trailer’s biggest success is its most important, and for the first time, fans see that Robert Downey Jr.’s Doctor Doom feels like a distinct character in his own right.

Related

Robert Downey Jr. Finally Feels Like Doctor Doom

The Trailer Has Won Over Hesitant Fans

Avengers: Doomsday’s first trailer had an enormous amount to introduce. Thor, Sam Wilson’s Captain America, Yelena Belova, the Fantastic Four, and the returning X-Men all appear, while also confirming that Chris Evans’ Steve Rogers is once again part of the story. However, despite all of the iconic Marvel characters involved, the trailer’s biggest job was establishing Doctor Doom. Marvel had already revealed Downey’s costume and confirmed he would be playing Victor Von Doom, but the trailer gave audiences their first substantial opportunity to hear and see how he would inhabit the character.

Doom opens the footage with an ominous warning about an approaching threat and an “unthinkable decision,” immediately giving Downey a vocal register far removed from the rapid-fire delivery of Tony Stark. The trailer also keeps Doom deliberately obscure, using the mask, hood, and carefully controlled framing to establish the character as a looming presence rather than relying on the audience recognizing Downey’s face. Garnering 66 million impressions on X (formerly Twitter) and almost 30 million on YouTube, the trailer flashes through multiversal icons like Loki, Ant-Man, and the original X-Men before ending with a pained confrontation by Reed Richards.

Related

Even if it doesn’t hit the same unbeatable high set by the Avengers: Infinity War trailer, the trailer successfully proved Marvel’s casting decision. The announcement itself created an innate comparison, given how well audiences know Tony Stark’s voice, humor, mannerisms, and history. Doom, therefore, had to feel different from the get-go, and fans’ reactions confirm that Doomsday has already cleared that hurdle with Downey’s line delivery, dominating presence, heavy accent, and complete detachment from Stark’s charismatic personality.

The Avengers: Doomsday Trailer Didn’t Succeed in Every Aspect

The Upcoming Marvel Movie Might Have Another Obstacle to Overcome

Despite its enormous scale, ensemble characters, and Downey’s hyped villain, the trailer wasn’t a complete success. One of the loudest criticisms has focused on the Russo Brothers’ visual style, with fans concerned that scenes suffer from flat color grading and artificial-looking CGI. The Thor and Doctor Doom confrontation, in particular, has become a major talking point, with viewers questioning the visual effects and bleak, debris-covered environment surrounding the two characters.

Endgame and Infinity War still possessed some visual vibrancy, particularly in the Titan fight. Given the success of those two massive Avengers movies, they established a sense of occasion that many viewers are now using as the standard against which Doomsday is being judged. Recent MCU movies have had a unique visual identity that complemented their atmosphere and story; Thunderbolts had a moody atmosphere that did not eliminate the richness just because there were neutral tones, and Fantastic Four: First Steps boasted a vibrant and distinct color palette. Of course, the Doomsday trailer doesn’t necessarily represent the finished film, and some of the visual effects will likely be refined before the movie hits theaters. But, even though it proved Downey can work as Doctor Doom, it seems Doomsday has other things to prove.

Related

Avengers: Doomsday Has Still Managed to Change the Conversation

Too Much of Doomsday Discourse Focused on Doctor Doom

In Doomsday, beloved heroes from three distinct universes, including Earth-616’s Avengers, the Fantastic Four, and the X-Men, are thrust onto a deadly collision course. Together, they must unite to confront an unprecedented existential threat unleashed by the villainous Doctor Doom, a master of cutting-edge science and powerful magic intent on reshaping reality. Casting Robert Downey Jr. strongly implies a multiversal twist or a variant connection to Tony Stark that does not exist in mainstream Marvel lore.

Two trailers are out, and only five months remain until Doomsday releases, but Marvel has kept huge parts of the plot under wraps. Besides the fact that multiversal heroes will be teaming up against Doctor Doom, not even Sebastian Stan knows the plot (although this might just be a tactic to avoid revealing the story). Given this, most of the conversation around the upcoming MCU movie has centered on Downey’s casting. It would’ve taken away from the story at hand if audiences only saw Tony Stark every time Doom was on-screen, but with the latest trailer, Marvel has changed the discourse and Victor finally feels like his own character. It’s clear that some genuine concerns still exist around Avengers: Doomsday, but Downey’s casting no longer feels like the film’s biggest problem. Thankfully, fans have a reason to forget Tony Stark for long enough to accept him as Doctor Doom.